Just so you know, if you click on a product on toasterovensonline.com and decide to buy it, we may earn a small commission.
Having a tough time finding the best toaster oven for you?
Many of our readers have told us that they don’t know where to start when trying to choose a toaster oven which will best suit their needs.
That is where we come in; we have spent hours researching the best toaster ovens on the market and went through hundreds of hours of testing so you don’t have to.
Trust us when we say we did our research, we reviewed the full spectrum of toaster oven brands including Oster, Breville, Black and Decker and Hamilton Toaster Ovens.
QUICK ANSWER: BEST TOASTER OVEN
- Oster Toaster Oven
- Black & Decker Toaster Oven (6 slice)
- Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven
- Black & Decker Toaster Oven (4 slice)
- Breville Mini Smart Oven
- Bella Toaster Oven
Toaster Oven – Ultimate Buyer’s Guide
You can read the review highlights of the best buy toaster ovens below, read our in-depth reviews for each toaster oven and see customer reviews to better understand which toaster oven is best for you!
1. Oster Large Capacity Countertop 6-Slice Digital Convection Toaster Oven
Best Large Capacity Toaster Oven
Do you need a large capacity toaster oven built to handle more than typical toaster ovens?
Whether you live in a small space, or need to cook a big family meal and simply can’t create any more space in your regular oven, the Oster 6-slice toaster oven is a great choice.
You can cook entire meals inside this thing, including a small chicken, turkey or rack of delicious baby back ribs!
The Oster utilises “convection technology” which in simple terms means that your food will be cooked evenly and thoroughly with no frozen centres or burnt edges that you sometimes experience with budget models.
It also features a neat touch control panel and convenient LCD display, both of which are easy to use.
In summary, the Oster 6-slice toaster oven is perfect if you need a larger capacity toaster oven.
I have had my Oster for a few years now and find it ideal for cooking small family meals or during big family occasions where my conventional oven is simply not big enough to cook everything that I need to.
PROS
- Large capacity
- Convection technology
- Easy to use
CONS
- Requires large kitchen space
2. Black and Decker 6-Slice Toaster Oven
Best Value Large Capacity Toaster Oven
When you think of Black and Decker, toaster ovens are not the first choice that springs to mind.
That said, they have built a solid reputation for producing good toaster ovens which perform well at a fraction of the cost of some of their competitors.
The Black and Decker 6-slice is no exception.
The toaster oven has preset cooking functions for pizzas, frozen snacks, potatoes, baking and broiling – all of which can be selected with the touch of a button.
You can also adjust the cooking time and/or temperature manually which I really like because it enables you to override the preset options in case you need to make some adjustments to ensure your food is cooked perfectly.
With its 8 one-touch functions and deep interior, the Black and Decker 6-slice toaster oven performed very well when we tested a variety of foods.
My personal favourite was the baking convection setting which circulates hot air around the oven for faster, more even cooking.
If you are looking for a reliable 6-slice toaster oven at an affordable price then this could be the perfect option for you.
PROS
- Great value
- Stylish design
- Large capacity
- Convection Technology
CONS
- Requires larger kitchen space
3. Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven
Best Design Toaster Oven
The Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven is a great little toaster oven, what I really like about it is the unique door design which works similar to a bread basket where the curved door slides upwards to allow you easy and safe access to your food in the oven.
Since the door opens upward it allows you to reach your food without having the door in your way.
I can’t tell you how many times I’ve accidentally burned my arm on the inside of the open toaster oven door. I love this design!
In addition to its unique door design, the Hamilton Beach toaster oven comes with a slide-out rack which is easy to clean, allows you to remove hot food safely and helps your food cook more thoroughly.
Similar to the Black & Decker 4-slice toaster oven, this comes with easy-to-use dials which allow you to adjust temperature and cooking time with minimal fuss.
Overall this is a great toaster oven with a unique easy reach design which makes cooking easier and safer.
PROS
- Unique door design which provides safe and easy access
- Easy to use dials
- Can take up to 4 large slices of bread or pizza
CONS
- Does not have 6-slice capacity
4. Black and Decker 4-Slice Toaster Oven
Best Value Toaster Oven
While it may not have all the bells and whistles of the other options reviewed here, you wouldn’t expect that and if you are just looking for a cheap and simple toaster oven then this is an excellent choice.
With 3 easy-to-understand dials, this oven is really simple to use and perfect if you don’t want a confusing control panel and a ton of options.
All you have to do is select the temperature, cooking style and time that you want to cook for – easy!
The first dial controls the temperature setting, which is very helpful when you are cooking food such as pizza which requires a specific heating temperature.
If you want to cook toast simply select the “toast” setting – easy!
The second dial allows you to select the type of cooking e.g. baking, broiling, toasting or simply keeping something warm.
The third dial is a timer setting which enables you to select how long you wish to cook your food for.
In summary, the Black and Decker 4-slice toaster oven is a great buy and perfect if you are looking for a cheap and easy-to-use toaster oven.
PROS
- Easy to use and handle
- Can take up to 4 large slices of bread or pizza
- 4 dedicated cooking functions
CONS
- Toasting can sometimes be uneven
- The door handle is sensitive and needs to be handled with care
5. Panasonic Toaster Oven
Best Value Toaster Oven
The Panasonic Flash Xpress may look a bit outdated but make no mistake this toaster oven offers superior cooking performance at a budget price.
Indeed it outperformed many of its (more expensive) rivals in testing thanks to the patented Panasonic “infrared heating technology” which ensures your food is cooked evenly and quickly.
It is smaller than many of the other models we tested here and would suit those who are looking for a space saving toaster oven for their kitchen countertop.
PROS
- Cooking performance
- Great value
- Easy to use
- Compact Design
CONS
- Not a very stylish design
- Limited capacity
6. Bella Toaster Oven
Bella house ware is a well-known brand however they are not so commonly known in the world of toaster ovens so it was exciting for us to have the opportunity to test the Bella toaster oven.
With 1,200 watts power output and quartz heating technology, this model performed really well cooking quickly and evenly when we tested it with a range of foods including toast, salmon, chicken, pizza and bagels!
And what’s more, with five presets to choose from and a removable crumb tray we found cooking and cleaning the Bella toaster oven to be an absolute breeze.
Overall, we were impressed with the Bella model because it’s easy to use, toasts well in all five of the preset settings and the removable crumb tray makes cleaning a breeze.
The stylish brushed metal exterior and simple dials make this an attractive toaster oven which is also user-friendly.
PROS
- Simple dials are easy to use
- 5 preset settings
- Stylish design
CONS
- Exterior heats up quickly
- Limited capacity
7. Breville Mini Smart Toaster Oven
Best Quality Toaster Oven
If you are willing to increase your budget to get a higher quality toaster oven then the Breville Mini Smart toaster oven could be just what you are looking for.
In addition to its superior build quality, 1,800 watts of power output, the Breville features Element IQ technology which ensures that the heat is evenly distributed for the type of food you want to cook.
There are eight preset cooking functions including broil, roast, pizza, reheat, cookies, toast, bake and bagel (who said toaster ovens are just for cooking bread or pizza?) which can be easily selected using the touch panel.
Other neat features of this toaster oven include an LCD display which lights up orange when it’s preheating and blue when not in use, a rack which can be placed in any of the three positions, a pull-out crumb tray, a warming tray and a non-stick interior which makes cleaning the Breville effortless.
PROS
- Eight dedicated presets
- Powder coated steel housing
- 4-slice capacity
CONS
- It can take a while to get accustomed to its settings
- Pricey
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.